Complete Guide To Transmission Swap: Manual And Automatic

The transmission plays a pivotal role in transferring power from the engine to the wheels, determining how efficiently and smoothly the vehicle operates. 

In this article, we will delve into the nitty-gritty of a transmission swap, exploring the differences between manual and automatic transmissions, examining the benefits and drawbacks of each, and addressing common questions and concerns that arise in such projects. 

By the end, you will have gained valuable insights to help you decide if a transmission swap is right for your vehicle and how to carry it out effectively.

So, let’s proceed with the journey of understanding and executing transmission swaps with confidence and precision.

Transmission swap

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links, which can provide a small compensation to me at no cost whatsoever to you if you decide to purchase from them. This supports the website significantly and allows more quality content to be created. All product or brand promoted is carefully selected and judged to be a beneficial purchase.

what is a transmission swap?

Transmission swaps involve the replacement of a vehicle’s existing transmission with a different one, be it for performance enhancement, improving fuel efficiency, or overcoming transmission-related problems.

It is a complex undertaking that demands meticulous planning, a good understanding of automobile mechanics, and the right tools and expertise.

Why Do a Transmission Swap?

Undertaking a transmission swap is a significant decision, and car owners may have various compelling reasons to embark on such a modification. The following are some common motivations that can prompt individuals to consider a transmission swap:

Performance Enhancement

Car enthusiasts and performance-driven drivers often seek a transmission swap to tailor their vehicle’s performance to their specific preferences. For example, converting from an automatic to a manual transmission can offer greater control over gear selection, potentially leading to improved acceleration and more engaging driving experiences.

Conversely, an automatic transmission can provide convenience and seamless gear shifts, which might be preferred for daily commuting or traffic-heavy routes.

Addressing Transmission Issues

Transmission problems can be a major headache for car owners. When faced with a malfunctioning or irreparable transmission, a swap with a compatible and reliable replacement becomes a viable solution.

It can restore the vehicle’s functionality and reliability, avoiding the need for costly repairs or replacements of the same type.

Availability

Many of the more popular car amongst car enthusiasts can be very hard to find at a good price. Often times, if it is cheap the car is damage or as different problems.

However, automatic version of those cars will often be a few grand cheaper and in great condition simply because they are automatic. Therefore, if you are willing to put the time, you can save a few bucks on your dream project car.

Increasing Towing Capacity

In cases where a vehicle’s original transmission does not meet the desired towing requirements, a transmission swap to one with higher towing capacity may be pursued. This can be particularly relevant for owners of trucks, SUVs, or other towing-capable vehicles.

Potential Performance Improvements

The choice of transmission can significantly impact a vehicle’s overall performance. Apart from the specific benefits mentioned earlier, a well-executed transmission swap can lead to several potential performance improvements:

Acceleration

Swapping to a transmission with gear ratios tailored for quicker acceleration can enhance the car’s responsiveness and ability to reach higher speeds more efficiently.

Handling and Control

Some drivers may find that a manual transmission provides better control over the vehicle, especially in demanding driving conditions or when tackling challenging terrains.

Power Delivery

Different transmissions can influence how power is delivered to the wheels. A transmission that optimizes power delivery can result in smoother acceleration and improved torque.

Engine RPM Range

The choice of transmission can affect the engine’s operating RPM range. A well-matched transmission can keep the engine operating in its optimal power band, maximizing performance and efficiency.

Manual vs. Automatic: The Difference in Performance

The choice between a manual and automatic transmission can significantly influence the driving experience and overall performance of a vehicle. Each transmission type has its unique characteristics, which cater to different driving styles and preferences.

Manual Transmission

Manual transmissions, also known as “stick shifts,” require the driver to manually engage and disengage gears using a clutch pedal and a gear lever (shifter). These transmissions offer several performance-related advantages:

  • Control and Engagement: With a manual transmission, drivers have more control over gear selection. This control allows for precise gear changes, making it possible to optimize acceleration, engine braking, and gear ratios according to driving conditions.
  • Performance Enthusiasts: Car enthusiasts often favor manual transmissions because they provide a more engaging and hands-on driving experience. The ability to shift gears at will and master the art of “heel-toe” downshifting can enhance driving enjoyment.
  • Fuel Efficiency: In certain situations, manual transmissions can deliver better fuel efficiency compared to automatics. Skilled drivers who can match gear changes to the engine’s power band may achieve improved gas mileage.

Automatic Transmission

Automatic transmissions, on the other hand, offer a more convenient and user-friendly driving experience. These transmissions shift gears automatically, allowing the driver to focus solely on acceleration and braking. Some performance-related aspects of automatic transmissions include:

Smooth and Seamless Gear Shifts: Automatic transmissions provide smooth gear changes, which enhance overall comfort, particularly during stop-and-go traffic. This seamless operation can also be beneficial for drivers seeking a more relaxed and hassle-free driving experience.

Ease of Use: Automatic transmissions eliminate the need for manual gear shifting and clutch engagement, making them more accessible for drivers with limited experience or physical limitations.

Consistency and Reliability: Automatic transmissions tend to be less demanding on drivers and vehicle components, leading to reduced wear and tear over time. This can contribute to increased longevity and lower maintenance costs.

Quicker Shifting: Unfortunately, it is undeniable that technology is quicker than humans in certain things and shifting through gears is one of them. This is why automatic or sequential transmission are often used in drag cars as it helps to shave extra time.

Ultimately, the decision between a manual and automatic transmission boils down to personal preferences, driving habits, and the intended purpose of the vehicle. Whether seeking a spirited driving experience, optimal fuel efficiency, or maximum convenience, understanding the performance characteristics of each transmission type is essential in making an informed choice. When contemplating a transmission swap, this knowledge becomes invaluable in determining the most suitable transmission for achieving specific driving goals.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Manual and Automatic Transmissions

Both manual and automatic transmissions have their merits and drawbacks, and the choice between the two depends on individual preferences, driving habits, and intended vehicle use:

Manual Transmission

Benefits of Manual Transmissions

  • Greater control over gear selection, useful for performance-oriented driving.
  • Engaging driving experience for enthusiasts who enjoy a hands-on approach.
  • Potential for improved fuel efficiency.
  • Simpler design, which can lead to lighter weight and potentially better power-to-weight ratios.

Drawbacks of Manual Transmissions

  • Requires more effort and skill to operate, which can be less appealing in heavy traffic or for drivers seeking a more relaxed driving experience.
  • Can be challenging for beginners or those not accustomed to driving manual vehicles.
  • Slightly higher risk of premature clutch wear with inexperienced drivers.

Automatic Transmission

Benefits of Automatic Transmissions

  • Ease of use and convenience, making driving more accessible and less demanding.
  • Smooth gear changes, contributing to a comfortable ride and reduced driver fatigue.
  • Suitable for drivers with physical limitations or those who prefer a more relaxed driving style.

Drawbacks of Automatic Transmissions

  • Reduced direct control over gear selection, which may not appeal to performance enthusiasts.
  • Slightly lower fuel efficiency compared to skilled manual transmission drivers.
  • Typically heavier and more complex, potentially affecting power-to-weight ratios.

Tools and Parts Needed for a Transmission Swap

Best tools for a successful transmission swap

Undertaking a transmission swap is a complex and precise process that requires the use of specialized tools to ensure a successful and efficient modification. Before embarking on the project, it is essential to assemble a comprehensive set of tools to facilitate the smooth execution of the swap. Some essential tools for a transmission swap include:

essential parts for the transmission swap

In addition to the essential tools, acquiring the appropriate parts for the transmission swap is critical. The specific parts required will depend on the nature of the swap, in this case converting from automatic to manual. Some of the important parts needed for a successful transmission swap include:

  • Transmission
  • Fly Wheel and Clutch Assembly
  • Mounts and Bushings
  • Clutch Pedal
  • Slave Cylinder and Lines
  • Manual Driveshaft
  • Pilot Bearing
  • Extra Bolts and Stuff
  • Rear Main Seal (Optional)

How perform a transmission swap Step-by-step

Considering that a transmission swap is a pretty big and technical project we consider that following an article can be a bit difficult and may even be a bad idea.

This is why we will keep this article to the major and important point without going super in depth. Therefore, you can use this section of the article as a checklist and or a guide to help you through you process.

If you are unsure of what you are doing we recommend you call a buddy who might have done a transmission swap before or even a real mechanic you know well and might want to help you.

If these are not an option we recommend you watch the video bellow made by donut media:

You might also be interested in the video made by ChrisFix HERE

The first steps to the transmission swap

1. remove shifter

The first step before you jack up the car will be to remove the shifter and all the other parts connected to the transmission from the interior of the car. In our article about short shifters HERE you can learn about removing a manual shifter.

2. Jack up th car

Now that you have removed everything connected from the car to the transmission you can start jacking the car up. It is very important that you secure the car properly on jack stands.

Not only are you gong to spend 90% of this job underneath the car but your are also removing a major and heavy component of the car which will change the weight balance. We recommend you use 4 jack stands for this particular job to properly secure the car but to also make your life easier working underneath it.

Remove the automatic transmission

1. Drain the transmission

This step is pretty straight forward. You want to drain the transmission fluid (via the transmission drain plug) before you remove it to avoid a mess.

2. Remove connected and Surrounding parts

Remove all the parts connected to the transmission and any surrounding parts that may interfere with the removal. This can include:

  • Exhaust Piping
  • Drive Shaft
  • Automatic transmission cooler and lines (For automatic transmissions)
  • Starter

3. Unbolt the transmission

The next step in the transmission swap process is to unbolt the transmission. Make sure you have a jack underneath the transmission as you start unbolting it.

Pro Tip: The jack can help you with the harder to reach bolts by jack up or down titling the transmission and motor giving you more room to work with.

4. remove the automatic transmission

Once you have removed the majority of the bolts you can place your transmission jack underneath the tranny (transmission) and prepare to lower it down. Secure the tranny to your jack, remove the final bolts and lower the transmission.

Prepare for manual transmission installation

1. Install clutch pedal, lines, and slave cylinder

Driving a manual without a clutch might be a bit of a problem. You can watch the video above to help you with this step. (Time 9:00)

2. Rear main seal and pilot bearing

Back underneath the car, you want to remove the automatic flex plate. Afterwards, while the transmission is off if your rear main seal is getting old it can be a good idea to replace it right away. Otherwise, you can continue by installing the pilot bearing.

3. Install flywheel

Next step on the transmission swap checklist in to install the flywheel. Add some thread lock to the flywheel bolts and torque them down to manufacturer specs. You will need to lock the flywheel in place with a pry bar or the proper adapter to torque the bolts.

4. install clutch assembly

Next step in to install the clutch assembly. Again, you can watch the video above to help you with this step. (Time 12:45)

5. prepare the new manual transmission

There is a few thing you want to do to the transmission while it is out of the car Such as lubing and preinstalling harder to reach parts once the tranny installed. (Time 15:15)

Installing the manual transmission

For this step and even the previous steps check out the following ChrisFix video

1. Jack it up and bolt it on

The transmission swap is almost done. Jack up the new tranny and bolt it on.

the last steps to the transmission swap

1. install shifter

now that the transmission swap is done, time to do the final steps. The first one consists of connecting the shifter handle to the transmission for inside the car.

2. Install and bleed slave cylinder

Next you will need to install and bleed the slave cylinder. You can watch the following video from CM Autohaus or from Lupien_life

3. Reinstall all connected or surrounding parts

Reinstall all the connected or surrounding parts you removed earlier.

4. Disconnect automatic transmission computer

The automatic transmission require a computer to control it. Since the car no longer has an automatic tranny you can disconnect the computer from the car. This might cause a check engine light which you can remove with a scan tool. (Time 18:35)

test drive

Finally, you have completed your transmission swap. Test is out in a safe place.

where to buy a transmission for a transmission swap

Transmission swap FAQs

How much does a transmission swap cost?

The cost of a transmission swap can vary significantly depending on many factors, including the type of transmission, the vehicle’s make and model, and whether new or used parts are used. You can use the following numbers as a guideline. However, once again this can vary greatly.

  • Transmission: $1000
  • Clutch and Flywheel: $850
  • Mounts and Bushings: $150
  • Clutch Pedal: $100
  • Slave Cylinder and Hydraulic Lines: $125
  • Manual Driveshaft: $850
  • Extras: $75 – $100
  • Total: Approximately $3175

How hard is it to perform a transmission swap?

Swapping a transmission is a complex project that can require a good level of mechanical knowledge and technical expertise. The difficulty level can vary based on the specific vehicle and transmission type involved.

However, a transmission swap is a fun project that is worth the time. Additionally, you might learn a thing or two.

What are some common reasons why people consider transmission swaps?

People consider transmission swaps for various reasons. Common motivations include seeking performance improvements, addressing transmission-related issues or failures, customizing their driving experience, increasing towing capacity, or enhancing fuel efficiency.

Car enthusiasts often pursue transmission swaps to align their vehicles with their specific driving preferences and achieve a more engaging and enjoyable driving experience.

How does the choice of transmission impact a vehicle’s performance?

Manual transmissions provide more control over gear selection. On the other hand, automatic transmissions offer convenience and smooth gear changes, making them ideal for stop-and-go traffic and effortless driving. Continuously variable transmissions (CVT) prioritize fuel efficiency and seamless power delivery, while dual-clutch transmissions (DCT) provide lightning-fast gear changes for high-performance applications.

Are there any benefits to converting from automatic to manual or vice versa?

Converting from automatic to manual or vice versa can offer specific benefits depending on driving preferences and intended use. Converting to a manual transmission can provide more control over gear selection and potentially improve acceleration, making it popular among performance enthusiasts. On the other hand, converting to an automatic transmission can enhance convenience and ease of use, particularly in heavy traffic or for drivers seeking a more relaxed driving experience.

How can a transmission swap affect a vehicle’s resale value?

A transmission swap can impact a vehicle’s resale value, depending on the extent of the modification and the preferences of potential buyers. While some enthusiasts may value performance-enhancing swaps, others may prefer vehicles with original factory specifications. 

How long does a transmission swap take?

Generally speaking, a transmission swap can be done over the weekend.

However, this will vary greatly depending on different factors such as, your knowledge, where you are working, if you have help, the car model and more. Yet, a weekend is a good ballpark number for someone with good mechanic knowledge, working alone or with a friend at home.

Can a transmission swap be done at home?

Yes, absolutely a transmission swap can be done at home. Although it is easier with a 2 post lift a transmission swap can be done alone in your driveway.

Conclusion

In conclusion, transmission swaps are significant automotive modifications that significantly impact a vehicle’s performance and driving experience. They require careful planning, technical expertise, and understanding of potential challenges.

This guide covers transmission types, tools, parts, and preparation, as well as vehicle compatibility, safety considerations, and resale value.

Professional assistance is essential for efficient and safe swaps. Each vehicle and transmission swap is unique, so being well-informed, patient, and methodical is crucial. Seeking advice from experienced mechanics, enthusiasts, or professionals is essential for a smooth and proficient swap.